What's shown in your screenshot should normally set the sort order for that folder (but no other folders, and not sub-folders).
If you're seeing something else when you enter that folder, hover the mouse over the icon on the status bar to find out where the current folder format came from.
I'm sorry to be dense, I've played with so many options at this point.
I just want one lister on the left with a tab sorted descending by modified date each time I open, two more tabs in different locations sorted normally.
On the right another lister with a single tab, different location, sorted normally.
I would like those to be the same each time DO starts.
This is what the tab which doesn't maintain its sort shows:
I've tried saving the individual "Folder Format" for the path over and over with the proper sort. It shows as a "favorite". Problem is, I just want that sort to be kept for one tab, and I would like it each time I start or navigate back to the tab.
I wanted to follow up with a reply. I really never felt like I was doing anything "wrong". I did have some misgivings about layouts vs tab groups vs other things, but felt I understood enough to be making good decisions.
I eventually ripped out large swaths of settings, tab groups, etc. Once done, I closed, re-opened, and re-added things from the ground up. Now, the sorting maintains itself between launches. I wish I could tell you I did something different, but I don't feel that I did.