Please migrate Directory Opus to native Linux

I tried "Worker" some time ago..

I don't think it makes much sense to use it, it has a weird interface by todays standards, what GUI standard or framework is it actually using? It looks totally out of place.. o) There was no context menu either and weird handling when selecting files if I remember correctly.

Double Commander is the same thing, they are all weird in one way or another.

There is no way around programming something usable from scratch I think, something which adheres to modern standards and makes use of a flexible customization system and scripting.

The best file manager right now I think is Krusader (in theory), it lacks a preview pane though, which is a no-no for me nowadays, it only supports dual panel mode and it has some cosmetic issues as well, but from a functional perspective, it kind of makes sense.

Right now I use Thunar nightly on Linux, self compiled from their source repository to be able to use the latest fixes and little enhancements, you need every little enhancement there is to get along. It's the only one allowing to switch from single to dual panel, have a preview pane (which only works for images for some reason, but at least a preview! o), it also has tabs and can toggle vertical and horizontal dual panel mode.

To toggle the panels or dual/horizontal, you have to do some funky batch scripting and you can only toggle things for ALL the Thunar windows currently open (wtf! o).

Thunar also has some hidden options you need to check out if you want to squeeze the most out of it and it has "Custom Actions", a very bare bones way to add custom functionality to the context menu or toolbar, but be aware, this is nowhere near what DO has to offer.

You probably also need to hack the CSS for Thunar to be able to make use of the two panels successfully, since which one has focus is not distinguishable with the default settings, uurgs! It's a lot of work and there are basically no CSS classes inside the Thunar executable to make life easy.

But after you did all the compiling and hacking, you have an emergency file manager, which dims the pane which does not have focus, something the Linux world has never seen before! o) (I could not get the icons to dim, but spacing, coloring, margins and font sizes, it's way better already.).

2 Likes

Agreed, Worker has lots of issues/bugs, e.g. with the window/buttons layout, default-modal (!) transfer dialogs, etc.

I'm trying the version of Thunar supplied by the Linux Mint repo, and it seems rather good so far, but with some niggles. I may try a newer version later.
One thing I like, is it says it saves/restores the window tabs, so I hopefully won't have to keep reopening regularly used tabs/paths again; that was on of the many things which DOpus got right too, but some Linux Desktop FMs annoyingly don't do this!

1 Like

Thunar yes, it is able to restore tabs iirc, but it has no concept of layout or standard lister or something. So a "restore tabs" might work as expected for a single windows, after you entered the desktop, but it won't work properly if you ended your last session with multiple Thunar windows e.g., because Thunar only saves "current tabs" in a single place for a single window.

Same issue as the horizontal vs. vertical split.. it only saves in one place, that's why ALL the windows switch presentation if you toggle this setting around. Kind of ridiculous.. same goes for the preview pane if I remember correctly. Not sure why the Linux crows get's along with this..

At least the Dolphin developers make clear, their file manager is not for "Steve", the professional user. You can read about "Steve" on their Github landing page or in their documentation. Unfortunately, they don't tell you what file manager "Steve" should use instead.. o)

2 Likes